Liz Buchanan BVSc MRCVS
Keymaster
Hello - I hear your frustration and trust that your vet was equally as frustrated. The answer, of course, is a quibbly one: what did you mean when you say that the surgery felt unnecessary? If you mean that your dog would have been no worse off if they hadn't have had the surgery in this case, then from the information that you have given me, I am inclined to agree. However, the real question is, whether your vet could have predicted as much before the exploratory laparotomy took place, or whether they needed to carry out the surgery in order to know that your dog was safe. If the exploration had found a foreign body and thereby saved your dogs' life, then you would all have been very pleased that it took place. I was an emergency surgeon at one stage in my career and have attended whole lectures on the subject: 'to cut (operate) or not to cut.' The decision is regrettably not always clear cut and if all foreign bodies are to be found in good time, then it may be inevitable that some 'negative' exploratory laprotomies (ie surgeries that dont help anything) take place. Now, I cannot see the scans and may be no more experiencd in this area than your veterinary surgeon, so I am not the person to judge the decision that your vet made. You could ask the vet retrospectively about their decision, or ask an ultrasonography or surgical expert to review the notes and say how they would have called it. Your vet may already have asked the same of their colleagues, because in my experience, vets are perfectionists and put a lot of pressure on themselves to 'call it right' every time. The bottom line is that I would always rather explore the gut and find nothing than fail to explore the gut and miss something. The reality is that a GP vet acts at hospital-consultant level in a number of different disiplines (your human GP would never have to make such a call) and that in order to at peace with themselves, vets have to accept that we probably do more negative ex-laps than our human medical colleagues. I hope that something here helps.
Report