If your pet has ever needed a procedure at the vet, then you may have signed a consent form. While this captures your permission to perform the procedure described in the form, would that alone count as “informed consent”? The short answer is probably not. Informed consent is a two-way conversation between the vet team and the owner, not just a piece of paper. Let’s explore this further…
What is informed consent?
Informed consent involves two main components: a verbal discussion as well as a written consent agreement. A signed form on its own is not enough. The consent discussion may take place with a veterinary nurse (especially for a routine procedure), or with the veterinary surgeon.
To give informed consent, owners must be given time to process the information given to them and ask questions. You need to fully understand your pet’s medical situation, the procedure or treatment recommended, and the risks involved to be able to give informed consent. An upfront discussion about costs is also needed. Informed consent acts like a contract between you and the veterinary practice, with a signed form being the easiest way to document this.
Informed consent involves –
Explaining the diagnosis and options
Vets must explain the diagnosis (or tentative diagnosis), as well as the various reasonable treatment options. This may also include no intervention at all or euthanasia. Vets must discuss the expected benefits of these options.
Outlining risks and complications
As well as the chances of success, vets must explain the most common risk factors or side effects to you, including possible anaesthetic or surgical complications.
Financial estimates
Clear cost estimates must be produced for pet owners to help them decide how to proceed. A discussion around cost implications for any potential complications may also need to be had. For example, if the surgery does go wrong, what further costs could be incurred? While it’s hard to predict every single outcome, owners need to be aware that things may not end at the initial estimate alone.
Checking understanding
Vets need to clarify medical terms, avoid using technical jargon, and invite the pet owners to ask questions. These questions may be at the time of the consultation or via follow-up emails or phone calls. It can be helpful to write things down or ask for an owners’ handout, as it can be difficult to retain all the information relayed in a consultation.
Checking contact details
Vets need to ensure the client is contactable during the animal’s treatment so that additional verbal permission can be obtained if the treatment plan or costs change. Many consent forms contain contact preferences which need checking when a patient is being admitted into the hospital.
Ensuring whoever gives consent is authorised
The vet needs to feel satisfied about who is giving their signature for consent – is it the registered owner? Or is it an agent whom the owner has permitted to sign on their behalf (for example, a dog-sitter or relative).
Ensuring informed consent – a professional responsibility
The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, of which all practicing UK vets have to be members, has a code of conduct which veterinary professionals are obliged to uphold – failure to do so may be considered professional misconduct. One area that the RCVS is very clear on is the need for informed consent –
‘11.2 Informed consent, which is an essential part of any contract, can only be given by a client who has had the opportunity to consider a range of reasonable treatment options (including euthanasia and the option to monitor the animals without further tests or treatment), with associated fee estimates, and had the significance and main risks explained to them. In all cases, unless it would cause a delay that would adversely affect the animal’s welfare (i.e., in an emergency), the client’s consent to treatment must be obtained. For non-urgent procedures, where possible, the consent discussion should take place in advance of the treatment.’
This supporting guidance also goes on to discuss many of the points we listed in the above section. While informed consent is something that vets strive to achieve, there are occasions where this is not feasible, which we will discuss later.
Ensuring informed consent – an owner responsibility
As mentioned previously, informed consent is a two-way conversation, so you need to play your part too –
Ask questions
If you don’t understand anything that has been discussed, make sure to ask questions. Your vet won’t mind, and most are often straightforward to discuss. Asking questions may help put your mind at rest and also shows you have listened and processed what your vet is saying.
Provide up-to-date contact details and remain contactable
Your vet may need to get hold of you during your animal’s hospitalisation or procedure, especially if there are new findings or your pet’s condition has changed. Nothing is more frustrating to a vet with a hospitalised animal than not being able to get hold of an owner, so keep your phone nearby! If they can’t get hold of you, then they will be unable to update the treatment plan, which could affect your pet’s care.
You should also keep your pet’s microchip details up to date so that you can be contacted if your pet is ever brought to a veterinary practice in an emergency.
Consider language barriers
If English is not your first language, then consider bringing a friend or relative along to your appointments, so that they can help translate. If you struggle to understand what your vet is saying, you will be unable to give informed consent.
Make sure the person giving consent is authorised
Your vet needs to be sure that it is the animal’s registered owner giving consent, and in order to sign the consent form, you must also be over 18. If you are unable to be there, it is possible for an authorised party to give consent on your behalf. It’s helpful if the vet practice has been given this information in advance, so if you are planning a holiday and won’t be contactable, let your vet team know who will be responsible while you are away. This person must also be over 18 years of age.
What happens in an emergency or if the owner cannot be contacted?
In emergencies, animal welfare must always come first. Vets are bound by the declaration they made when joining the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons –
‘I promise and solemnly declare that I will pursue the work of my profession with integrity and accept my responsibilities to the public, my clients, the profession and the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, and that, above all, my constant endeavour will be to ensure the health and welfare of animals committed to my care.‘
The Animal Welfare Act 2006 is a law which allows vets to act to prevent an animal from suffering, even when consent is unclear, or the owner is absent. Vets have both an ethical and legal duty to ensure animals don’t suffer.
This not only covers stray animals, but also scenarios where an owner is unreachable (see the earlier point about keeping your phone to hand!), or where they decline essential treatment. This includes pain relief delivered at the point of care, but also euthanasia if it is deemed necessary on welfare grounds. The vet’s findings will be clearly documented in their notes, along with any other supporting evidence like lab results or photos.
In difficult situations where there is a big difference of opinion, and a vet has concerns about an animal suffering, then things may need to be escalated. If a client leaves the practice with a suffering animal and refuses care (or euthanasia), then this can be reported to a relevant local authority or a charity such as the RSPCA. In this scenario, your right to confidentiality/data protection is waived, and the police may become involved to intervene and uphold animal welfare laws.
This type of scenario is extreme, however. Most vets come to a solution with the pet owner after talking things through and exploring the various options, taking multiple factors into consideration.
Contextualised care, The Spectrum of Care Model and financial considerations in veterinary practices
When discussing informed consent, it’s also worth discussing contextualised care. Contextualised care is about vets adapting evidence-based information gained from research studies into real-world solutions. While research may point towards their idea of optimum treatment, the best option for the individual patient will depend on several factors, including –
- The animal’s condition, temperament and welfare needs
- The owner’s goals, opinions, finances, transport options, and capabilities. For example, a frail elderly owner may be unable to handle a grumpy cat, so the best treatment options for them may be very different to a situation with a more physically able owner and placid pet.
- The vets’ experience and the practice resources. For example, most first opinion (GP) practices won’t have advanced imaging or specialists available to them, so they may need to refer you for some of the available surgical or medical care.
- Availability of the treatment
So, while research may inform the decisions we make in practice, it must not completely dictate them. Contextualised care is an important part of informed consent. Vets must discuss all the various options, helping owners make decisions once they have all the relevant information.
Exploring this further, the Spectrum of Care (SOC) is a modern model which moves vets away from considering advanced, specialist-level care as ‘gold-standard’ and the only acceptable medical pathway. The SOC model emphasizes that there are multiple valid ways of providing good clinical care, while still upholding animal welfare. This shift away from the ‘gold-standard’ label helps to reduce guilt for pet owners who can’t afford this level of treatment and stops them feeling pushed towards euthanasia as the only other alternative.
A spectrum of care can be offered in many scenarios, but here is an example when considering a cranial cruciate ligament injury –
| Tier Level | Diagnostic Approach | Treatment strategy |
| Tier 1: Advanced | Specialist referral, advanced imaging and more comprehensive lab panels | Advanced surgical procedures, specialist intensive care, thorough rehabilitation programme, and follow up X-rays |
| Tier 2: Standard general practice | In-house radiography and standard bloodwork | In-house surgical repair with standard hospitalisation and cage rest |
| Tier 3: Conservative/basic | Physical examination findings and response to conservative treatment | Outpatient medical management, strict exercise restriction, repeat veterinary examinations and oral medications. |
| Tier 4: Palliative/euthanasia | Quality of life assessments and pain management | Symptomatic management, pain relief and humane euthanasia if pain cannot be controlled |
Now, clearly, each of these will carry different risks and benefits, which may affect patient outcomes – that is where informed consent comes in. Providing pet owners with options and discussing the various pros and cons, as well as the costs of each possible treatment choice, is the basis of informed consent. When presenting this information, vets should not make judgements as to an owner’s individual circumstances and should offer everything.
During conversations, other cost options should be considered, such as the possibility of direct pet insurance claims, spreading payment through external finance companies, or charity help. Relinquishment (rehoming or signing your pet over) may be another avenue that can be explored.
Vets do understand the emotional strain and guilt that unexpected bills can put on pet owners. So please, never hesitate to ask questions or discuss costs in more detail.
Summary
Informed consent is an essential part of veterinary medicine. For pet owners to be able to agree to treatment, they must first understand what is involved, the risks and benefits, the costs, and whether there are other options available too.
However, it is important to remember that informed consent is a two-way process which also relies on you asking questions and being contactable when needed.
If you have concerns about your pet’s care, or you are not sure whether you are able to give informed consent to a treatment plan, then be sure to raise it with your veterinary practice directly.
Discussion